4.10.4. New projects in the provision of legal aid
Various new initiatives by Member States contributed to building capacity for the provision of legal aid and the development of specialised legal aid services for international protection applicants. At the same time, civil society organisations contested some changes in the organisation of legal aid services and their funding. For example, when the AMIF-funded project on the provision of legal counselling in the asylum procedure ended in Czechia, the Ministry of the Interior launched a public tender for the provision of legal assistance in March 2022, inviting law firms and attorney offices to apply.Organisation for Aid to Refugees | Organizace pro pomoc uprchlíkům. (2019). Komplexní poradenství žadatelům o udělení mezinárodní ochrany II [Comprehensive advice to applicants for the granting of international protection II]. https://www.opu.cz/cs/2019/09/komplexni-poradenstvi-pro-zadatele-o-mezi… OPU raised concern about this new approach, especially that the awarded lawyers were not specialised in asylum matters, risking to undermine the quality of services.Organisation for Aid to Refugees | Organizace pro pomoc uprchlíkům. (2023). Input to the Asylum Report 2023. https://euaa.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2023-02/organization_for_aid… The NGO mentioned that, although the Ministry of the Interior intends to reopen the call for the provision of legal aid to NGOs, the lack of funding in 2022 resulted in a shortage of experienced staff.
In Slovenia, the Legal-Informational Centre for NGOS (PIC) contested the way the new AMIF call was organised. The call invited individual refugee counsels to apply, and NGOs were not able to participate. The call was not public but was instead sent to a limited number of refugee counsellors who were selected by the Ministry of the Interior; six were selected to provide aid between April-November 2022. Under the scope of the call, vulnerable and detained asylum seekers would be provided with free legal aid and representation to lodge an application, while others could be provided with the services during the personal interview if they asked for representation. PIC also raised concern with the low share of applicants provided with free legal aid and representation under the scheme.European Council on Refugees and Exiles. (2023). Input to the Asylum Report 2023. https://euaa.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2023-03/european_council_on_…
The Legal Aid Board in Ireland established a specialised sub-panel of lawyers who will provide legal aid in the international protection procedures as of 3 January 2023.https://www.legalaidboard.ie/en/lawyers-and-experts/legal-professionals… . Legal aid is provided to those who have been granted it by the board in connection with their application for international protection. The sub-panel is designed to be operational initially for 1 year with the possibility of an extension, aiming to facilitate the organisation of services. Applicants will continue to apply for legal aid in one of the three designated law centres (Smithfield in Dublin, Seville House in Galway and Popes Quay in Cork), which are authorised to check eligibility criteria and designate a lawyer from the sub-panel.European Union Agency for Asylum. (2022). Asylum Report 2022. https://euaa.europa.eu/asylum-report-2022 This is with the aim to alleviate current concerns raised by the Irish Refugee Council, which noted the general lack of capacity, leading to applicants being told to complete the questionnaire by themselves and many applicants waiting over 6 weeks to be assigned a representative by the Legal Aid Board.European Council on Refugees and Exiles. (2023). Input to the Asylum Report 2023. https://euaa.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2023-03/european_council_on_…
In Malta, aditus foundation welcomed the strengthened cooperation with the Migrant’s Advice Unit in the Agency for the Welfare of Asylum Seekers (AWAS), which is staffed with welfare officers who provide information on employment, housing, education, health and assisting with integration into the community. Since June 2022, an informal referral system was put in place for any beneficiaries of services residing in reception centres or in the community, where MAU can call or send an email to aditus lawyers to inquire about a more complex issue and refer the person appropriately.European Council on Refugees and Exiles. (2023). Input to the Asylum Report 2023. https://euaa.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2023-03/european_council_on_…
Convive Fondation Cepaim informed that bar associations in Spain were piloting their own International Protection Legal Assistance Offices since 2022, in cooperation with UNHCR.Spanish Law Association | Abogacía Española. (2022, October 11). ACNUR y el Consejo de la Abogacía abren una Oficina de Protección Internacional en Almería [UNHCR and the Law Association open an International Protection Office in Almería]. https://www.abogacia.es/actualidad/noticias/acnur-y-el-consejo-de-la-ab… The aim is to increase the knowledge and skills of legal practitioners providing assistance in the asylum procedure.
In Croatia, the Ministry of the Interior signed a new contract with the Croatian Law Centre on for the implementation of an AMIF-funded project, “Legal advice in the process of granting international protection”.European Migration Network. EMN Quarterly. January-March 2022. 38th Edition. https://emnbelgium.be/sites/default/files/publications/00_emn_38th_Quar… Information material on legal assistance in the international protection procedure was prepared in various languages and distributed to asylum applicants, including relevant versions for unaccompanied minors.Croatian Law Centre | Hrvatski pravni centar. (2022). Projekt „Pravno savjetovanje u postupku odobrenja međunarodne zaštite 2021.“: izrađeni i distribuirani informativni materijali za tražitelje međunarodne zaštite [Project "Legal advice in the process of approval of international protection 2021.": developed and distributed information materials for international protection applicants]. http://www.hpc.hr/2022/05/23/projekt-pravno-savjetovanje-u-postupku-odo…
In 2022, the Foundation for Access to Rights in Bulgaria continued to build its capacity to provide effective legal assistance through a new cross-border project on legal assistance for the family reunification procedure and the integration of beneficiaries of international protection.Foundation for Access to Rights | Фондация за достъп до права. (2022, August 1). Правна и финансова помощ за събиране на семейства [Legal and financial assistance for family reunification]. https://farbg.eu/bg/latest/pravna-i-finansova-pomosch-za-sbirane-na-sem… The project continued existing initiatives on legal aid provision at every step of the asylum procedure.Center for Legal Aid - Voice in Bulgaria. (2022, January 10). Ефективна правна помощ за бежанци и мигранти в България – Продължение [Effective legal aid for refugees and migrants in Bulgaria - Continuation]. https://www.centerforlegalaid.com/en/news/efektivna-pravna-pomosht-za-b… In total, 80 applicants benefitted from legal aid through an AMIF-funded project which targeted third-country nationals with special needs.Center for Legal Aid - Voice in Bulgaria. (2022, September 30). Закриващо събитие на проект „Подкрепа на уязвими лица измежду граждани на трети страни в процедура по връщане чрез прилагане на метода кейс мениджмънт и на алтернативи на задържането“[Closing event of the project "Supporting vulnerable third-country nationals in return procedures through case management and alternatives to detention"]. https://www.centerforlegalaid.com/bg/news/zakrivashto-sybitie-na-proekt… The project ended in October 2022.
In addition, the Bulgarian Helsinki Committee continued its legal aid project funded by UNHCR and offered advice to 2,383 applicants throughout 2022. The efforts were undertaken in the absence of state-provided legal aid for applicants in Bulgaria, apart from legal aid provided to asylum-seeking and refugee children.European Council on Refugees and Exiles. (2023). Input to the Asylum Report 2023. https://euaa.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2023-03/european_council_on_…
IOM Bulgaria implemented a project “Providing legal advice and interpretation for third-country nationals seeking protection” in 2022, targeting mainly vulnerable applicants. In total, about 400 third-country nationals seeking asylum benefitted from legal assistance at all stages of the procedure.
In Germany, a legislative proposal was drafted to include asylum procedure counselling independent from authorities that also allows special legal aid for the LGBTIQ community and applicants with special needs (it is part of the funding programme for independent counselling).
In Slovenia, the pilot project for the provision of free legal assistance to vulnerable asylum applicants ended in October 2022. Since then, with UNHCR funding, the civil society organisation PIC has been providing free legal assistance to asylum applicants.
